In developing and elaborating the theory of Attract-F, Chomsky (1995) propo
ses the mechanism of Generalized Pied-Piping. According to Chomsky, when a
formal feature of a head H attracts a matching feature of a category Psi, o
ther formal features of a category Psi can be moved automatically, without
any cost in terms of the general economy condition, to the target H togethe
r with the feature that is attracted to H. In this paper it will be demonst
rated, contra Chomsky's (1995) proposal, that the application of Generalize
d Pied-Piping should be somehow constrained by the economy condition as lon
g as the computation involved in the grammar of the human language (what Ch
omsky 1994 calls C-HL) is conducted only in a strictly derivational manner.
This paper, therefore, claims that Generalized Pied-Piping, just like Move
/Attract, is a kind of syntactic operation subject to the general economy c
ondition under the view that C-HL is strictly derivational.