Germany's more compressed wage structure is widely viewed as the main cause
of the German-US difference in employment and unemployment, but part of th
e compression is due to Germany having a narrower distribution of skills th
an the US. Even adjusted for skills, however, we find that Germany has a mo
re compressed wage distribution than the US. But relatively little of the U
S-German employment difference can be attributed to the compressed wage dis
tribution. We find that jobless Germans have nearly the same skills as empl
oyed Germans and look more like average Americans than like low skilled Ame
ricans, which runs counter to the wage compression hypothesis. Given these
patterns, the pay and employment experience of low skilled Americans is a p
oor counterfactual for assessing how reductions in pay might affect jobless
Germans.