Axial segregation is a well-known example of segregation of granular materi
als. However. at present, there is no conclusive explanation as to why it o
ccurs. Most studies of axial segregation to date are based on cylinders wit
h circular cross sections. and models focus on the character of the surface
flow without accounting explicitly for the influence of any subsurface det
ail. The present experiments demonstrate that the cross section of the mixe
r has a significant influence on axial segregation and that subsurface dyna
mics are, in fact, important. Unlike circular mixers, in square mixers the
subsurface segregation patterns change with filling level. as does the time
dependence of axial segregation. Furthermore, when radial segregation patt
erns in noncircular mixers most closely resemble that observed for circular
cylinders, the time dependence for axial band formation deviates: the most
. These results challenge segregation theories of axial segregation that ig
nore subsurface effects.