We address one key source of the known discrepancies between theory and exp
eriment in poroelasticity, i.e,, the fact that Gassmann's equations for the
bulk and shear moduli predict that the shear modulus is independent of the
saturating fluid properties, whereas it is observed on the contrary that a
t high enough frequencies the shear modulus can in fact depend on the fluid
's elastic properties in many porous materials. One clue to understanding t
his behavior comes from effective medium theory, which shows that the shear
modulus does depend on the fluid properties in many circumstances. In comp
arison to values predicted by effective medium theory, Gassmann's equations
predict different, smaller values for both the effective bulk and shear mo
duli of porous media. Sorting through these apparent (but not actual) disag
reements among theory and theory, and theory and experiment is the main thr
ust of the paper.