Populations of most bird species associated with grassland, shrub-scrub hab
itats, and disturbed areas in forested habitats (hereafter all referred to
as disturbance-dependent species) have declined steeply. However, a widespr
ead perception exists that disturbance-dependent species are merely returni
ng to population levels likely found by the first European explorers and se
ttlers. The fact that many disturbance-dependent bird species and subspecie
s are now extinct, globally rare, threatened, or endangered challenges that
perception and raises the question of balance between conservation efforts
for birds dependent upon disturbances and birds more closely associated wi
th mature forests. An overall understanding of the status and trends for th
ese disturbance-dependent species requires reconstruction of at least thous
ands of years of Native American land use followed by 500 years of post-Eur
opean settlement. Interpretations herein on how to manage for these disturb
ance-dependent species should support efforts to conserve all landbirds in
eastern North America.