Leaf analysis could assist in adjusting the P fertilization of potato (Sola
num tuberosum L.) to specific soil-plant systems to achieve high yield cond
itions. Our objective was to derive and validate Compositional Nutrient Dia
gnosis (CND) norms and ranges for a potato cultivar (Superior) and to compa
re CND to Diagnosis and Recommendation Integrated System (DRIS) and the Cri
tical Value Approach (CVA). Survey data were obtained from 563 field observ
ations and validated using 100 independent samples and across four P fertil
izer trials. The databases included tuber yield and analyses (N, P, K, Ca,
and Mg) of the upper fully expanded leaf collected at beginning of bloom. Y
ield cutoff between low- and high-yield subpopulations, selected from cumul
ative variance functions across survey data, was 34.1 Mg ha(-1). The sum of
squared values of CND indexes was distributed like a chi-square value, The
critical chi-square value was 4.2, The critical CND P index range was betw
een -0.80 and 0.80. Similar critical values were obtained for the validatio
n population and fertilizer trials. The CND P index appeared symmetrical ab
out the zero nutrient balance and was more closely related to yield compare
d with DRIS and CVA, The CND provides an inferential las chi-square) and sy
mmetrical (about zero balance) diagnosis at low cost, could provide nutrien
t index ranges adjusted to yield goal, and could thus be developed advantag
eously for specific soil-plant systems.