Mh. Gerrits et al., An evaluation of nonresponse bias in peer, self, and teacher ratings of children's psychosocial adjustment, J CHILD PSY, 42(5), 2001, pp. 593-602
Citations number
78
Categorie Soggetti
Psychiatry
Journal title
JOURNAL OF CHILD PSYCHOLOGY AND PSYCHIATRY AND ALLIED DISCIPLINES
The last decades have shown a rapid increase in nonresponse rates. For this
reason it is important to study nonresponse and think about it critically.
In this article we investigated whether nonresponse affected estimates of
the levels of adjustment problems in children and the correlations between
these outcomes. The nonresponse was caused by parents who refused permissio
n to interview their children at school, parents who did not return a quest
ionnaire. teachers who did not complete the questionnaire. and parents who
refused to participate in an in-depth study, with nonresponse rates of 9 %,
69 %, 25 %. and 46 % respectively. The sample consisted of 1282 children a
ged 4-5 years and the dependent measures were peer-rated sociometric status
, self-rated wellbeing at school, and teacher-rated behaviour problems. Des
pite considerable nonresponse in some conditions our results showed hardly
any evidence for bias. This suggested that bias cannot simply be inferred f
rom the amount of nonresponse and that standard rules such as "nonresponse
rates higher than 50 % are not acceptable " lack a scientific basis. Instea
d, we argue that to assess nonresponse bias the specific conditions and ana
lyses of the study will need to be considered and special measures may be r
equired.