Retributive responses play a role in human behavior. Are they triggered pri
marily by supposed intentions or by observed consequences of actions? Exper
imental studies were conducted of retributive responses in situations in wh
ich the individual actor may inflict harmful consequences without intending
to and intend harmful consequences without inflicting them. Results indica
te that retributive responses are more strongly influenced by observed cons
equences than ascribed intentions. However, individual retributive motivati
ons seem to be overshadowed by concerns that are nonretributive altogether,
in that they focus on end-state distributions independently of who brought
them about.