Fruit flies of the genus Drosophila have independently invaded deserts arou
nd the world on numerous occasions. To understand the physiological mechani
sms allowing these small organisms to survive and thrive in arid environmen
ts, we performed a phylogenetic analysis of water balance in Drosophila spe
cies from different habitats. Desert (cactophilic) species were more resist
ant to desiccation than mesic ones. This resistance could be accomplished i
n three ways: by increasing the amount of water in the body, by reducing ra
tes of water loss or by tolerating the loss of a greater percentage of body
water (dehydration tolerance). Cactophilic Drosophila lost water less rapi
dly and appeared to be more tolerant of low water content, although males a
ctually contained less water than their mesic congeners, However, when the
phylogenetic relationships between the species were taken into account, gre
ater dehydration tolerance was not correlated with increased desiccation re
sistance. Therefore, only one of the three expected adaptive mechanisms, lo
wer rates of water loss, has actually evolved in desert Drosophila, and the
other apparently adaptive difference between arid and mesic species (incre
ased dehydration tolerance) instead reflects phylogenetic history.