The lack of pervasive flooding of the South Pole-Aitken (SPA) basin raises
questions about the mare basalt source region models, whether deep or shall
ow. This paper investigates the dichotomy between the nearside Imbrium-size
d flooded basins and the unflooded SPA basin by modeling the effects of gia
nt impacts on the dynamics of the lunar mantle. We allow an initially spher
ically symmetric Moon model to evolve through mantle convection for a few h
undred million years and then let an Imbrium- or SPA-sized impact occur. Th
e subsequent thermal convection in the lunar mantle resulting from the ther
mal energy introduced by an impact is determined for the next 100 m.y. The
mantle is assumed to be incompressible, with an infinite Prandtl number and
a temperature-dependent viscosity. It is shown that the mantle circulation
induced by an Imbrium-sized impact can only slightly push aside the radioa
ctive-rich potassium, rare earth element, and phosphorous (KREEP) layer fro
m beneath the surrounding crust. This concentrates the radioactive elements
beneath the low-thermal-conductive ejecta blanket and provides a suitable
condition for enhancement of radioactive heating and subsequent partial mel
ting and basaltic flow to the basin. On the other hand, a SPA-sized impact
is capable of generating mantle circulation vigorous enough to strip away t
he KREEP layer from beneath the surrounding crust within a time period of 4
0 m.y. This removal prevents radioactive heating and partial melting beneat
h the surrounding crust, thus explaining the lack of flooding of SPA basin.
These results are insensitive to the time of impacts but are strongly depe
ndent on their sizes.