article looks at the new arrangements for strategic land use planning polic
y in the English regions and the questions that these arrangements raise fo
r the successful implementation of policy. It then turns to the case of Lyo
n, France, which has had a rather longer history of strategic plan-making b
oth at regional level and in the conurbation. It concludes that scale of op
eration, administrative arrangements and political influence all have had a
major bearing on both the formulation of policy and its likely success in
practice.