Using a nonlinear critical layer analysis, we examine the behavior of distu
rbances to the Holmboe model of a stratified shear layer far Richardson num
bers 0 < J less than or equal to 1/4, regarding J as an O(1) quantity rathe
r than a small quantity. By examining the structure of the solution inside
the critical layer, we demonstrate that, for this particular flow, disturba
nces with a phase change of the form predicted by linear stability theory c
annot exist on a purely linear basis, and because of this, an instability w
ave. will have no phase change across the critical layer, and that instead
we should regard the Richardson number J as a small quantity within the fra
mework of a nonlinear analysis. We argue further that when nonlinear effect
s are included; disturbances with a phase change can exist, but this leads
to such a slow time scale that the flow in question is unlikely to arise, e
xcept possibly as a secondary instability.