T. Masud et al., Distal forearm fracture history in an older community-dwelling population:the Nottingham Community Osteoporosis (NOCOS) study, AGE AGEING, 30(3), 2001, pp. 255-258
Objectives: to assess the prevalence of a history of Colles' fracture (occu
rring after the age of 40 years) and to ascertain the extent of investigati
on and treatment of osteoporosis in this population.
Methods: we studied subjects aged greater than or equal to 60 years from th
e age-sex register of three general practices. We recorded a history of fra
ctures and details of any previous investigation for osteoporosis and treat
ment with bone-protective drugs. Bone mineral density was performed at the
heel using dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (Lunar PIXI machine). We classi
fied subjects into normal, osteopaenic or osteoporotic according to the mac
hine manufacturer's recommended World Health Organisation 'equivalent T-sco
re thresholds' (0.6 for osteopaenia and 1.6 for osteoporosis).
Results: of the 605 subjects invited, we recruited 259 women and 194 men (r
esponse rate=74.8%). Twenty-eight (10.8%) of the women and five (2.6%o) of
the men had a history of Colles' fracture. Of women with a prevalent Colles
' fracture, 39% were osteoporotic and 36% were osteopaenic. These rates wer
e significantly greater than in women without a Colles' fracture (19.9% ost
eoporotic, 29.4% osteopaenic; P=0.018). Assuming the same PIXI thresholds f
or men, two (40%) of the five men with a history of Colles' fractures were
osteoporotic and the rest were osteopaenic, compared with 20.6 and 31.2% of
men without a history of Colles' fractures. None of the subjects in the Co
lles' fracture group had previously been investigated with bone densitometr
y. Women with and without a history of Colles' fracture did not differ sign
ificantly in ever having (32.1% vs 27.2%; P=0.4) or currently having (14.3%
vs 10.4%; P=0.4) hormone replacement treatment. None of the men and only o
ne woman with a previous Colles' fracture had ever taken a non-hormone repl
acement treatment for osteoporosis.
Conclusions: older community-dwelling subjects with previous Colles' fractu
re have a high prevalence of osteoporosis and are under-investigated and un
der-treated. Methods for identifying subjects with a previous Colles' fract
ure need to be developed in primary and secondary care.