The validity of dream recall is discussed. What is the relation between the
actual dream and its later reflection? Nielsen proposes differential sleep
mentation, which is probably determined by dream accessibility. Solms argu
es that REM sleep and dreaming are double dissociable states. Dreaming occu
rs outside REM sleep when cerebral activation is high enough. That various
active sleep states correlate with vivid dream reports implies that REM sle
ep Mid dreaming are single dissociable states. Vertes & Eastman reject that
REM sleep is invoked in memory consolidation. Considerable evidence for th
us was obtained by REM deprivation studies with the dubious water tank tech
nique.