Re. Kenward et al., Density and linkage estimators of home range: Nearest-neighbor clustering defines multinuclear cores, ECOLOGY, 82(7), 2001, pp. 1905-1920
Methods used to estimate home ranges from point locations are based either
on densities of locations or on link distances between locations. The densi
ty-based methods estimate ellipses and contours. The other class minimizes
sums of link distances, along edges of polygons or to range centers or betw
een locations. We propose a new linkage method, using nearest-neighbor dist
ances first to exclude outlying locations and then to define a multinuclear
outlier-exclusive range core (OEC) by cluster analysis. The assumption beh
ind exclusion of outliers. that movements inside and outside range cores in
volve different activities, was supported by data from radio-tagged Common
Buzzards (Buteo buteo). We compared the new method with other techniques by
using location data from each of 28 goshawks, 114 buzzards, 138 gray squir
rels, and 14 red squirrels. Range structure statistics from OECs showed mar
ked differences between species in numbers and extent of core nuclei. Range
analysis displays illustrated relationships of range area with age categor
ies, food supply. population density, and body mass within species. The OEC
S gave highly significant results in three of five within-species tests, pe
rhaps because animal movements in these cases were affected by coarse-grain
ed habitat boundaries. When movements were likely to have been influenced b
y diffuse social interactions and foraging for scattered prey, the most sig
nificant results were from density-based estimators, especially kernel cont
ours that had been optimized by least-squares cross validation. We recommen
d use of both density and linkage estimators of home range until a basis fo
r a priori choices has been established.