Benthic animals can take up trace metals both from the sediment compartment
in which they burrow and from the water column compartment above their bur
rows (we define both compartments as containing water and particles). If cr
iteria for the protection of benthic animals are based on metal concentrati
ons in one of these two compartments, then it should first be demonstrated
that the majority of the metal taken up by these animals comes from the giv
en compartment. To determine whether benthic animals take up the majority o
f their cadmium (Cd) from the sediment compartment, we created a Cd gradien
t in lake sediment and compared Cd accumulation by the invertebrates coloni
zing these sediments with Cd concentrations in the sediment compartment. On
the basis of this relationship and using a bioaccumulation model, we estim
ate that indigenous benthic invertebrates take up the majority of their Cd
from the water column compartment. The results of our experiment are simila
r to those from a previous study conducted on a different benthic community
in a larger lake. Taxa common to both lakes obtained similar proportions o
f their Cd from the water column compartment, suggesting that Cd accumulati
on by the same species will be constant across lakes of differing size and
chemistry. Our results strengthen the argument that the protection of benth
ic communities from metal pollution should consider metal in both the water
column and sediment compartments. In this regard, the AVS model, which con
siders only sedimentary metals, was more effective in predicting Cd concent
rations in pore waters than those in most animal taxa. We suggest that meas
urements of vertical chemical heterogeneity in sediments and of animal beha
vior would aid in predicting the bioaccumulation and effects of sedimentary
pollutants.