Re. Westacott et al., Stability of ionic and radical molecular dissociation pathways for reaction in supercritical water, J PHYS CH B, 105(28), 2001, pp. 6611-6619
Molecular dynamics simulations have been used to examine the effect of supe
rcritical water solvent density on the competition between reaction pathway
s for the dissociation step of a model S(N)1 reaction. The effects are inve
stigated using an empirical valence bond theory that explicitly includes th
e effects of solvation, particularly those on the diabatic ionic state. At
low supercritical water densities, the solvent stabilization is insufficien
t to give rise to a local minimum on the free energy surface corresponding
to a contact ion pair intermediate, although the free energy surface is com
pletely ionic in character to solvent densities less than 0.05 g cm(-3). Th
e nature of the surface is also changed by solvent density; the change from
a mostly covalent (80%) molecule to completely ionic dissociation products
is decreasingly rapid as supercritical water density is decreased. Radial
density functions reflect how solvation changes along the reaction coordina
te and how local density enhancement provides the solvation required to sta
bilize the ionic products. These calculations indicate that the diabatic io
nic state is lowest in free energy until extremely low supercritical water
solvent density (similar to0.03 g cm(-1)), considerably lower than would be
expected if local density enhancement were ignored, as in a simple Born mo
del calculation. The free energy difference between the two pure states at
the dissociation plateau indicates that covalent products may be expected t
o reach approximately 22% of the total at the lowest density (0.0435 g cm(-
3)) considered here.