Despite the demonstrated efficacy of thermal biofeedback (TBF) for the
treatment of migraine headaches, therapeutic mechanisms underlying th
is widely used therapy remain poorly understood. Previous investigatio
ns of electromyograph (EMG) biofeedback treatment of tension-type head
ache have suggested that reductions in headache activity may be mediat
ed primarily by changes in perceived self-efficacy, rather than actual
self-regulation ability. The present study examined perceived self-ef
ficacy as a potential therapeutic mechanism in TBF using an experiment
al manipulation of perceived success. Twenty-seven females meeting Int
ernational Headache Society (IHS) diagnostic criteria for migraine hea
dache were randomly assigned to one of two TBF conditions. Subjects we
re shown bogus computer-generated graphs that ostensibly demonstrated
that subjects displayed either superior (high success condition) or in
ferior (moderate success condition) hand-warming skills relative to a
fictitious normative sample. Although the manipulation of perceived su
ccess produced significant group differences on measures of perceived
self-efficacy, the groups did not experience significantly different r
eductions in headache activity or medication consumption. The present
findings suggest that perceived self-efficacy, as measured in the pres
ent study, may not be a significant mediator of TBF treatment outcome.