A comparative investigation of hot dip Zn-25Al alloy, Zn-55Al-Si and Zn coa
tings on steel was performed with attention to their corrosion performance
in seawater. The results of 2-year exposure testing of these at Zhoushan te
st site are reported here. In tidal and immersion environments, Zn-25Al all
oy coating is several times more durable than zinc coating of double thickn
ess. At long exposure times, corrosion rate for the Zn-25Al alloy coating r
emains indistinguishable from that for the Zn-55Al-Si coating of similar th
ickness in tidal zone, and is two to three times lower than the latter in i
mmersion zone. The decrease in tensile strength suggested that galvanized a
nd Zn-55Al-Si coated steel suffer intense pitting corrosion in immersion zo
ne. The electrochemical tests showed that all these coatings provide cathod
ic protection to the substrate metal; the galvanic potentials are equal to
- 1,050, - 1,025 and - 880 mV (SCE) for zinc, Zn-25Al alloy and Zn-55Al-Si
coating, respectively, which are adequate to keep the steel inside the immu
nity region. It is believed that the superior performance of the Zn-25Al al
loy coating is due to its optimal combination of the uniform corrosion resi
stance and pitting corrosion resistance. The inferior corrosion performance
by comparison of the Zn coating mainly results from its larger dissolution
rate, while the failure of the Zn-55Al-Si coating is probably related to i
ts higher susceptibility to pitting corrosion in seawater.