Covariation of clutch size, laying date, and incubation tendency in the American Kestrel

Seasonal decline in clutch size is common in birds, but the proximate mecha nisms for this phenomenon have not been elucidated. The most credible model to date posits that late-laying females lay fewer eggs clue to a seasonal increase in the tendency to incubate during laying, which inhibits egg prod uction. We tested this model with free-living and laboratory American Kestr els (Falco sparverius) by quantifying changes in clutch size and incubation tendency during laying over the course of the breeding phase. Consistent w ith the model, clutch size in free-living kestrels decreased while incubati on increased with progress of the 74-day breeding phase. Inconsistent with the model, variation in incubation tendency during laying was not associate d with clutch size in either the field or the laboratory. In the laboratory , incubation increased but clutch size did not decrease over the course of the 77-day breeding phase. In the laboratory, females that nested early in one breeding phase renested more quickly and nested in a second breeding ph ase more quickly than females nesting late in the first breeding phase. Thi s indicates that timing of laying is, in part, a property of individual fem ales, independent of environmental factors. Together, our findings suggest that both clutch size and timing of laying are inherent, correlated propert ies of particular females. Although incubation tendency may influence clutc h size, other factors appear to override its influence.