Rsk. Mishra et al., Evidence for another low-temperature phase transition in tetragonal Pb(ZrxTi1-x)O-3 (x=0.515,0.520) - art. no. 054101, PHYS REV B, 6405(5), 2001, pp. 4101
Results of dielectric and resonance frequency (f(r)) measurements below roo
m temperature are presented for Pb(ZrxTi1-x)O-3, x = 0.515 and 0.520. It is
shown that the temperature coefficient of f(r) changes sign from negative
to positive around 210 and 265 K for x = 0.520 and 200 and 260 K for x = 0.
515. Anomalies in the real part of the dielectric constant (epsilon') are o
bserved around the same temperatures at which the temperature coefficient o
f f(r) changes sign because of the electrostrictive coupling between the el
astic and dielectric responses. Low-temperature powder x-ray-diffraction (X
RD) data, however, reveal only one transition from the tetragonal to monocl
inic phase similar to that reported by Noheda et al. [Phys. Rev. B, 61, 868
7 (2000)]. Electron-diffraction data, on the other hand, reveal yet another
structural transition at lower temperatures corresponding to the second an
omaly in the epsilon' vs T and f(r) vs T curves. This second transition is
shown to be a cell-doubling transition not observed by Noheda et al. in the
ir XRD studies. The observation of superlattice reflections raises doubts a
bout the correctness of the Cm space group proposed by Noheda et al. for th
e monoclinic phase of Pb(ZrxTi(1-x))O-3 below the second transition tempera
ture.