C. Cutler et al., Acute and chronic graft-versus-host disease after allogeneic peripheral-blood stem-cell and bone marrow transplantation: A meta-analysis, J CL ONCOL, 19(16), 2001, pp. 3685-3691
Purpose: Controversy exists as to whether the incidence of graft-versus-hos
t disease (GVHD) is increased after peripheral-blood stem-cell transplantat
ion (PBSCT) when compared with bone marrow transplantation (BMT). We perfor
med a meta-analysis of all trials comparing the incidence of acute and chro
nic GVHD after PBSCT and BMT reported as of June, 2000. Secondary analyses
examined relapse rates after the two procedures.
Methods: An extensive MEDLINE search of the literature was undertaken. Prim
ary authors were contacted for clarification and completion of missing info
rmation. A review of cited references was also undertaken. Sixteen studies
(five randomized controlled trials and 11 cohort studies) were included in
this analysis. Data was extracted by two pairs of reviewers and analyzed fo
r the outcomes of interest. Meta-analyses, regression analyses, and assessm
ents of publication bias were performed.
Results: Using a random effects model, the pooled relative risk (RR) for ac
ute GVHD after PBSCT was 1.16 (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.04 to 1.28;
P = .006) when compared with traditional BMT. The pooled RR for chronic GVH
D after PBSCT was 1.53 (95% CI, 1.25 to 1.88; P < .001) when compared with
BMT. The RR of developing clinically extensive chronic GVHD was 1.66 (95% C
I, 1.35 to 2.05; P < .001). The excess risk of chronic GVHD was explained b
y differences in the T-cell dose delivered with the graft in a meta-regress
ion model that did not reach statistical significance. There was a trend to
wards a decrease in the rate of relapse after PBSCT (RR = 0.81; 95% CI, 0.6
2 to 1.05).
Conclusion: Both acute and chronic GVHD are more common after PBSCT than BM
T, and this may be associated with lower rates of malignant relapse. The ma
gnitude of the transfused T-cell load may explain the differences in chroni
c GVHD risk.
J Clin Oncol 19:3685-3697. (C) 2001 by American Society of Clinical Oncolog
y.