Why do countries that impose employer sanctions to deter the illegal entry
of foreign workers nevertheless grant amnesty to illegal immigrants? In thi
s article, I provide a positive theory of amnesty provision in a model wher
e the constrained optimal immigration reform, involving the joint use of em
ployer sanctions and border interdictions, is time-inconsistent. In particu
lar, my framework demonstrates that host countries of immigration can enhan
ce the credibility of their immigration reforms by "binding their own hands
" and strategically granting a socially excessive amount of amnesty to ille
gal workers.