A comparison between two different irradiation effects was accomplished on
bulk YBCO samples synthesized with the quenched and melt growth method (QMG
-YBCO) to investigate strong pinning properties. High-energy proton-irradia
tion introduces small defects comparable to unit cell size into the sample,
and they act as effective pinning centers for all temperature range in low
field around I T. No enhancement, however, can be seen in higher field ran
ge. The defects introduced with the irradiation reinforce the pinning prope
rties of preexisting pinning centers randomly distributing in the sample. C
olumn-like defects with 3.5 GeV Xe-irradiation were introduced but the pinn
ing properties show no significant enhancement except higher temperature re
gion. This indicates that pre-existing pinning centers are strong enough th
an the columnar defects. In higher field region, the contribution of column
ar defects for pinning becomes relatively large. For both irradiation cases
, almost pinning properties are determined by the pre-existing pinning cent
ers. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.