L. Gothefors et al., Immunogenicity and reactogenicity of a new measles, mumps and rubella vaccine when administered as a second dose at 12 y of age, SC J IN DIS, 33(7), 2001, pp. 545-549
An open randomized trial involving 301 subjects was conducted in order to c
ompare the reactogenicity and immunogenicity of a new measles, mumps and ru
bella (MMR) vaccine, SB MMR, with those of a commercial MMR vaccine, Merck
MMR, when given as a second dose to children at 11-12 y of age. All subject
s had previously received Merck MMR in the first year of life. In initially
, seronegative subjects, all subjects receiving the Merck MMR vaccine had s
eroconverted with respect to measles (10/10 subjects), mumps (38/38) and ru
bella (4/4). Of the subjects receiving SB MMR, 6/7 seroconverted with respe
ct to measles, 29/31 with respect to mumps and 3/3 with respect to rubella.
No difference was seen in seroconversion rates or geometric mean values (G
MVs) between groups. In initially seropositive subjects, a higher anti-mump
s immune response rate was observed in the SB MMR group (59.3%) compared wi
th the Merck MMR group (24.1%.). Higher post-vaccination anti-mumps and ant
i-rubella GMVs were observed in the group receiving SB MMR (p < 0.007), whe
reas higher anti-measles GMVs were observed in the Merck MMR group (p = 0.0
013). There was a lower (p = 0.013) incidence of pain at the injection site
in subjects receiving SB MMR (20.1%) compared with Merck MMR (33.3%). Inci
dences of systemic reactions were similar between groups.