We hypothesized that short-term variation in airway caliber could be quanti
fied by frequency distributions of respiratory impedance (Zrs) measured at
high frequency. We measured Zrs at 6 Hz by forced oscillations during quiet
breathing for 15 min in 10 seated asthmatic patients and 6 normal subjects
in upright and supine positions before and after methacholine (MCh). We pl
otted frequency distributions of Zrs and calculated means, skewness, kurtos
is, and significance of differences between normal and log-normal frequency
distributions. The data were close to, but usually significantly different
from, a log-normal frequency distribution. Mean lnZrs in upright and supin
e positions was significantly less in normal subjects than in asthmatic pat
ients, but not after MCh and MCh in the supine position. The lnZrs SD (a me
asure of variation), in the upright position and after MCh was significantl
y less in normal subjects than in asthmatic patients, but not in normal sub
jects in the supine position and after MCh in the supine position. We concl
ude that 1) the configuration of the normal tracheobronchial tree is contin
uously changing and that this change is exaggerated in asthma, 2) in normal
lungs, control of airway caliber is homeokinetic, maintaining variation wi
thin acceptable limits, 3) normal airway smooth muscle (ASM) when activated
and unloaded closely mimics asthmatic ASM, 4) in asthma, generalized airwa
y narrowing results primarily from ASM activation, whereas ASM unloading by
increasing shortening velocity allows faster caliber fluctuations, 5) acti
vation moves ASM farther from thermodynamic equilibrium, and 6) asthma may
be a low-entropy disease exhibiting not only generalized airway narrowing b
ut also an increased appearance of statistically unlikely airway configurat
ions.