The higher level phylogenetic relationships within the avian feather lice (
Insecta: Phthiraptera: Ischnocera) are extremely problematic. Here we inves
tigate the relationships of I family (Goniodidae), sometimes recognized as
distinct within Ischnocera, using parsimony and likelihood analyses of nucl
ear and mitochondrial DNA sequences. These data support monophyly for a res
tricted definition of traditional Goniodidae, but recognition of this famil
y would result in paraphyly of the large heterogeneous family Philopteridae
. We show that the New World Chelopistes is not related to other members of
Goniodidae, despite similarities in morphology, but rather is the sister t
axon to Oxylipeurus. Within Goniodidae, genera are divided into those occur
ring on Galliformes (the Goniodes complex) and those occurring on Columbifo
rmes (the Coloceras complex). Within the well-sampled Coloceras complex, or
Physconelloidinae, several groups are identified. However, traditionally r
ecognized genera such as Coloceras and Physconelloides appear to be paraphy
letic. Whereas the phylogeny of Goniodidae reflects some aspects of host re
lationships, biogeography also influences coevolutionary history.