Aj. Tortolani et al., STUDENT PERCEPTIONS OF SKILLS ACQUISITION DURING THE SURGICAL CLERKSHIP - DIFFERENCES ACROSS ACADEMIC QUARTERS AND DEVIATIONS FROM FACULTY EXPECTATION, Teaching and learning in medicine, 9(3), 1997, pp. 186-191
Background: Individual and experiential factors, as well as the timing
of the surgical clerkship, may influence knowledge and/or skills acqu
isition. Purpose: To examine differences across academic quarters in s
tudent perceptions of skills acquisition; differences between student
perceptions and faculty expectations; and the association between perc
eptions and grades, student evaluations of the program, and their own
career interests. Methods: Each of 61 students evaluated postclerkship
acquisition of 33 procedural and 12 clinical skills. Each of 14 facul
ty surgeons indicated expectations for skills acquisition. Results: Fa
culty expectations were significantly higher (p <. 01) than first quar
ter (121) student perceptions for most skills. 121 student perceptions
were significantly lower than those of third quarter (Q3) students fo
r most skills. Perceptions of skills acquisition were associated with
preclinical desire for a surgical career, number of procedures perform
ed, number of workups completed, and clinical grade. Conclusion: Stude
nt perceptions of skills acquisition vary with the timing of the clerk
ship and reflect an interaction between individual and experiential fa
ctors, suggesting a need for increased standardization.