What is further fate of a published scientific paper?

Authors
Citation
O. Exner, What is further fate of a published scientific paper?, CHEM LISTY, 95(8), 2001, pp. 498-503
Citations number
47
Categorie Soggetti
Chemistry
Journal title
CHEMICKE LISTY
ISSN journal
00092770 → ACNP
Volume
95
Issue
8
Year of publication
2001
Pages
498 - 503
Database
ISI
SICI code
0009-2770(2001)95:8<498:WIFFOA>2.0.ZU;2-G
Abstract
Acceptance of a published paper may be different as shown on examples from the author's work. A wrong finding was rebutted (acyl derivatives of oximes , configuration of hydroximoyl chlorides), a method was accepted but not al ways followed (isokinetic relationship), a long-term discussion started whi ch has not been resolved (resonance in nitrobenzene), a work was repeated w ithout knowledge of the predecessor (acylation of a hydroxylamine derivativ e) or the paper was accepted but not cited (polyvalent iodine derivatives). The consequences are discussed from the philosophic, ethical, psychologica l and scientometric viewpoints.