Employing a mathematical model we show how insularity, genotypic interactio
ns and victim life-history/demography can influence adaptation in a simple
enemy-victim interaction where genotypes migrate between a large source and
a smaller, initially unoccupied, isolated habitat. We find that when there
are explicit costs to heightened enemy virulence and victim resistance, la
rge/close islands resemble their immigration sources, whereas small and/or
distant islands tend to be occupied only by the least defended victims and
least virulent enemies. In a model with no explicit cost to genotypic ident
ity, frequencies do not differ on average between source and island. Despit
e these trends in genotype frequencies, for a range of realistic conditions
, both cost and cost-free genotypic interactions yield an increase in the f
requency of resistant encounters as a function of isolation. Moreover, in m
odels with explicit costs, maximal island to island variation in genotypic
frequencies is found on islands of intermediate distance from the source. I
n contrast, the model without explicit costs produces more variable communi
ties, attaining maximum variability in genotypic frequencies at the most is
olated islands. We hypothesize that adaptive patterns in mainland-island co
mparisons may differ substantially from those generated by centre-periphery
comparisons in continental systems.