Mj. Kim et al., Two-stage reconstruction of bilateral alveolar cleft using Y-shaped anterior-based tongue flap and iliac bone graft, CLEF PAL-CR, 38(5), 2001, pp. 432-437
Objective: When an alveolar cleft is too large to close with adjacent mucob
uccal flaps or large secondary fistula following a primary bilateral palato
plasty exists, a one-stage procedure for bone grafting becomes challenging.
In such a case, we have used the tongue flap to repair the fistula and cle
ft alveolus followed by bone grafting to the cleft defect performed several
months later. The purpose of this article is to report on our experiences
with the use of an anteriorly based Y-shaped tongue flap to fit the palatal
and labial alveolar defects and on the ultimate result of the bone graft.
Patients: A series of 14 patients were treated with this approach from Janu
ary 1994 to December 1998. The average age of the patients was 15.8 years (
range 5 to 28 years). The mean period of follow-up following the second sta
ge bone graft operation was 45.9 months (range 9 to 68 months). In 9 of the
14 patients, the long-fork type of a Y-shaped tongue flap was used for ext
ended coverage of the labial-side alveolar defects with the palatal fistula
; in the remaining patients, the short-forked design was used.
Results: All patients demonstrated a good clinical result after the initial
repair of cleft alveolus and palatal fistula. There was no fistula recurre
nce, although partial necrosis of distal margin in long-forked tongue flap
occurred in one patient. Furthermore, the bone graft, which was performed a
n average of 8 months after the tongue flap repair, was always successful.
Occasionally, transferred tongue tissue bulging interfered with the hygieni
c care of nearby teeth; however, these problems could be solved with proper
contour-plasty performed afterward. No donor site complications such as se
nsory disturbance, change in taste, limitations in tongue movement, normal
speech impairments, or tongue disfigurement were encountered.
Conclusion: This two-stage reconstruction of a bilateral cleft alveolus usi
ng a Y-shaped tongue flap and iliac bone graft was very successful. It may
be indicated for a bilateral cleft alveolus patient in which the direct clo
sure of the cleft defect with adjacent tissue or the buccal flap is not eas
y because of scarred fibrotic mucosa and accompanied residual palatal fistu
la.