Kk. Baldridge et al., DOES PI-SIGMA-PI THROUGH-BOND COUPLING SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASE C-C BOND LENGTHS, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 119(30), 1997, pp. 7048-7054
Orbital effects ascribed to pi-sigma-pi through-bond coupling are the
result primarily of destabilizing filled-filled interactions; little t
o no mixing occurs between the antisymmetric pi combination and sigma
. The magnitude of through-bond coupling does not correlate with bond
lengthening. Previous conclusions that through-bond coupling induces l
ong bonds relied in some cases on poor X-ray data and/or inappropriate
molecular orbital theories to deduce geometries. Comparison of semiem
pirical and empirical force field data as a test for through-bond coup
ling is unwarranted. Standard force fields underestimate the steric bu
lk of the benzene face, but addition of so-called ''through-bond coupl
ing'' terms does not provide a physically significant measure of throu
gh-bond coupling.