Wi. Robinson, Transnational processes, development studies and changing social hierarchies in the world system: a Central American case study, THIRD WORLD, 22(4), 2001, pp. 529-563
Globalisation is bringing about changes in social hierarchies in the world
capitalist system which traditional categories and frameworks in developmen
t studies and macro-sociologies are unable to capture. Under globalisation
processes of uneven accumulation are unfolding in accordance with a social
and not a national logic. The increasing subordination of the logic of geog
raphy to that of production and the rising disjuncture between the fortunes
of social groups and of nation-states, among other processes, demand that
we rethink development. The social configuration of space can no longer be
conceived in the nation-state terms that development theories posit but rat
her as processes of uneven development denoted primarily by social group ra
ther than territorial differentiation. Social polarisation, the fragmentati
on of national economies, and the select integration of social groups into
transnational networks, suggest that development may be reconceived not as
a national process, in which what 'develops' is a nation, but in terms of d
eveloped, underdeveloped and intermediate population groups occupying contr
adictory or unstable locations in a transnational environment. The shift to
flexible accumulation worldwide and from an international to a global divi
sion of labour result in an increasing heterogeneity of labour markets in e
ach locale. Labour market participation becomes a key determinant of new so
cial hierarchies and of development conceived in social groups terms. Local
and national labour markets are themselves increasingly transnationalised,
part of a global labour market, in which differentiated participation dete
rmines social development. This article applies these propositions to a cas
e study of Central America, examining the changing fortunes of one particul
ar region under global capitalism and the lessons it offers for changing so
cial hierarchies in the world capitalist system and for a renewal of the so
ciology of development.