The level of ethnic violence increased in Eurasia after the Soviet collapse
. Two theories are tested to account for this increase. Horowitz's theory e
mphasizes psychological mechanisms affecting self-esteem. An alternative th
eory by Fearon and Van Houten, based on Brubaker's "triadic configuration,"
and relying on a commitment logic, emphasizes the level of an external hom
eland's support for a Tninority population in a nationalizing state. Tests
of these theories are performed on new data collected by the author from si
x post-Soviet republics (Estonia, Latvia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Moldova, and
Azerbaijan), only two of which experienced secessionist rebellion. The dat
a do not support the predictions that would follow from Horowitz's theory.
The commitment theory, however, is consistent with the data and the histori
cal record.