Multidisciplinary evidence suggests that people often make evaluative judgm
ents by monitoring their feelings toward the target. This article examines,
in the context of moderately complex and consciously accessible stimuli, t
he judgmental properties of consciously monitored feelings. Results from fo
ur studies show that, compared to cold, reason-based assessments of the tar
get, the conscious monitoring of feelings provides judgmental responses tha
t are (a) potentially faster, (b) more stable and consistent across individ
uals, and importantly (c) more predictive of the number and valence of peop
le's thoughts. These findings help explain why the monitoring of feelings i
s an often diagnostic pathway to evaluation in judgment and decision making
.