Particle size analysis was combined with titration data obtained in constan
t-composition, hydroxyapatite (HA)seeded. crystal growth assays. With addit
ion of large amounts of HA (250 mug), titration rates were linear, new crys
tal formation was minimal, and aggregation effects could be detected. With
addition of small amounts of HA (62.5 mug), nucleation of new HA was observ
ed. The effects of urinary macromolecules, i.e., osteopontin (OPN), recombi
nant glutathione-S-transferase-OPN (G-OPN), Tamm-Horsfall protein, chondroi
tin sulfate, human serum albumin, mixed urinary macromolecules from a stone
-former (SFU1), mixed urinary macromolecules from a normal individual (NU1)
, and polyaspartic acid (PA), were examined in this system. Crystal growth
inhibition, as measured by the slope of linear titration curves in this sys
tem, was observed with PA. G-OPN, OPN, SFU1, and NU1. All of the macromolec
ules tested inhibited aggregation, including Tamm-Horsfall protein, which d
id not inhibit growth. As reflected by the ratio of the final number of par
ticles to the initial number in the 62.5-mug seed addition, the macromolecu
les that were most effective in inhibiting growth, i.e., OPN, G-OPN, PA, SF
U1, and NU1, actually increased secondary nucleation. Recombinant G-OPN dem
onstrated less inhibitory activity than did OPN isolated from cell culture.
Chondroitin sulfate and human serum albumin exhibited no significant effec
ts on the various components of HA crystallization under these conditions.
SFU1 and NU1 slowed growth and increased secondary nucleation to similar de
grees, and neither exhibited any measurable effect on aggregation. Therefor
e, crystal surface sites that participate in nucleation, growth, and aggreg
ation processes are affected independently by macromolecules, presumably be
cause of differences in their structural features. These results illustrate
the utility of combining these techniques to provide a much greater unders
tanding of crystallization behavior than that possible with either analysis
alone.