I. Scoones, THE DYNAMICS OF SOIL FERTILITY CHANGE - HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVES ON ENVIRONMENTAL TRANSFORMATION FROM ZIMBABWE, Geographical journal, 163, 1997, pp. 161-169
Soil fertility is currently highlighted as a major issue for African a
gricultural development. But embedded within policy statements are a s
eries of underlying assumptions and methodological commitments. This p
aper questions these, arguing that an historical approach to understan
ding the dynamics of soil fertility change offers important insights o
f relevance to development policy and planning. Work on environmental
change in southern Zimbabwe emphasizes how issues of non-linear dynami
cs, spatial heterogeneity and the role of contingent events in precipi
tating change are important in understanding the nature of soils and t
heir management. Transformation of soils is seen to be the result of a
complex interaction of factors, mediated by a variety of social, econ
omic and political institutions over time. Such insights suggest a mor
e embedded, context-specific, adaptive and learning approach to interv
ention, which rejects simplistic, aggregated assessments of people-res
ource relationships, but instead takes uncertainty, complexity and the
potential for non-linear change seriously.