Fc. Wei et al., The outcome of failed free flaps in head and neck and extremity reconstruction: What is next in the reconstructive ladder?, PLAS R SURG, 108(5), 2001, pp. 1154-1160
The indications for free flaps have been more or less clarified; however, t
he course of reconstruction after the failure of a free flap remains undete
rmined. Is it better to insist oil one's initial choice, or should surgeons
downgrade their reconstructive goals? To establish a preliminary guideline
, this study was designed to retrospectively analyze the outcome of failed
free-tissue transfers performed ill the authors hospital.
Over the past 8 years (1990 through 1997), 3361 head and neck and extremity
reconstructions Were performed by free-tissue transfers, excluding toe tra
nsplantations. Among these reconstructions, 1235 flaps (36.7 percent) were
transferred to the head and neck region, and 2126 flaps (63.3 percent) to t
he extremities. A total of 101 failures (3.0 percent total plus the partial
failure rate) were encountered. Forty-two failures occurred in the head an
d neck region, and 59 in the extremities. Evaluation of the cases revealed
that one of three following approaches to handling the failure was taken: (
1) a second free-tissue transfer; (2) a regional flap transfer; or (3) cons
ervative management with debridement, wound care, and subsequent Closure by
secondary intention, whether by local flaps or skin grafting. In the head
and neck region, 17 second free flaps (40 percent) and 15 regional flaps (3
6 percent) were transferred to salvage the reconstruction, whereas conserva
tive management was undertaken in the remaining 10 cases (24 percent). In t
he extremities, 37 failures were treated conservatively (63 percent) in add
ition to 17 second free flaps (29 percent) and three regional flaps (5 perc
ent) used to sah,age the failed reconstruction. Two cases underwent amputat
ion (3 percent). The average time elapsed between the failure and second fr
ee-tissue transfer was 12 days (range, 2 to 60 days) ill the head and neck
region and 18 days (range, 2 to 56 days) in the extremities.
In a total of 34 second free-tissue transfers at both localizations, there
were only three failures (9 percent). However, in the head and neck region,
seven of the regional flaps transferred (47 percent) and four cases that w
ere conservatively treated (40 percent) either failed or developed complica
tions that lengthened the reconstruction period because of additional proce
dures. Six other free-tissue transfers had to be performed to manage these
complicated cases. Conservative management was quite successful in the extr
emities; most patients' wounds healed, although more than one skin-graft pr
ocedure was required in 10 patients (27 percent).
In conclusion, a second free-tissue transfer is, in general, a relatively m
ore reliable and more effective procedure for the treatment of flap failure
in the head and neck region, as well as failed vascularized bone flaps in
the reconstruction of the extremities. Conservative treatment may be a simp
le and valid alternative to second (free) flaps for soft-tissue coverage in
extremities with partial and even total losses.