To empirically discriminate between Ricardian and non-Ricardian behavi
our, we have to use a method that distinguishes between expected and u
nexpected, as well as permanent and transitory changes in taxes and go
vernment consumption. One method that provides these distinctions betw
een different types of changes is the common trends framework used in
this paper, which is a VAR model with cointegrating constraints. In th
e empirical study of US data, there is some support for the Ricardian
hypothesis, but there are also some deviations from its predictions. H
owever, the differences do not lend support to a Keynesian view of bud
get deficits, but rather to the view of expansionary fiscal contractio
ns. This can be motivated theoretically by uncertainty about future ta
xes in combination with prudent households.