Wa. Rice et al., Field comparison of pre-inoculated alfalfa seed and traditional seed inoculation with inoculant prepared in sterile or non-sterile peat, COMM SOIL S, 32(13-14), 2001, pp. 2091-2107
Rhizobium inoculant products in North America are often prepared using non-
sterile peat and may contain more contaminants than rhizobia. The effective
ness of sterile and nonsterile peat-based inoculants applied to alfalfa (Me
dicago sativa) seed using either traditional seed inoculation just before p
lanting, or pre-inoculated and commercially coated, were evaluated for thre
e years (eight harvests) at two sites in northwestern Alberta. Seeds inocul
ated just before planting had more rhizobia at planting time than pre-inocu
lated seed. When results from all the three years were combined, inoculatio
n with Rhizobium, either seed-applied or pre-inoculated, significantly (P <
0.05) increased nodule dry matter (DM) at both sites. However, the respons
e of forage N and DM yields to inoculation were significantly higher with s
eed application than with seed coating at one site, and vice-versa at the o
ther site. Differences resulting from the use of nonsterile peat or sterile
peat were not significant.