Db. Russell et al., Seroprevalence of herpes simplex virus types 1 and 2 in HIV-Infected and uninfected homosexual men in a primary care setting, J CLIN VIRO, 22(3), 2001, pp. 305-313
Background: Genital herpes is usually caused by herpes simplex virus type 2
(HSV-2), with infections often being unrecognised by patients and/or clini
cians. HSV-2 infections may be a risk factor for the transmission of human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. Reliable tests for type-specific HS
V antibodies are now readily available. Objectives: To determine the seropr
evalence of HSV-1 and -2 in HIV-seronegative gay men in a primary care sett
ing in Melbourne, Australia, and to compare it with the rate in HIV-infecte
d gay men. To assess the utility in a clinical setting of a type-specific H
SV enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) as compared with western blot.
Study design: We recruited a total of 300 HIV-seronegative homosexual men
attending for HIV antibody testing, and HIV-infected men attending for CD4
lymphocyte count and viral load estimation. The subjects completed a questi
onnaire, and sera were sent for total IgG HSV testing and testing by Gull t
ype-specific HSV ELISA assay. Selected serum samples were retested by weste
rn blotting and the results analysed. Results: In total, 168 HIV-antibody n
egative men and 132 HIV-antibody positive men were recruited. Of all subjec
ts, 73.3% had HSV-1 antibodies. This proportion did not differ between HIV-
seronegative and seropositive men (P = 0.48). About twenty percent of HIV-s
eronegative men and 61% of HIV-seropositive men had antibodies to HSV-2 (P
<0.0001); 75.6% of HIV-seronegative men with antibodies to HSV-2 gave no hi
story of genital herpes, as did 66.7% of HIV-seropositive men. Overall, in
using the type-specific ELISA (Gull) assay, false negative, false positive
or equivocal results were obtained in 33/300 (11%) of samples tested compar
ed with western blot. Conclusions: High rates of HSV-2 infection were found
in homosexual males, with the rate for HIV-seropositive men being over twi
ce that for HIV uninfected men. Most subjects were not aware of their infec
tion with HSV-2. HIV-infected individuals were also older and had higher nu
mbers of sexual partners, but we were unable to unambiguously establish tha
t these variables contributed to the difference in HSV-2 seroprevalence rat
es. The Gull type-specific assay for HSV antibodies has significant problem
s with sensitivity and specificity at a discrepancy rate of 11%. Caution is
advised in using this type-specific commercial assay for clinical purposes
. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.