J. Suni et al., Multicenter evaluation of the novel enzyme immunoassay based on P1-enriched protein for the detection of Mycoplasma pneumoniae infection, J MICROB M, 47(1), 2001, pp. 65-71
The aim of the study was to evaluate new Mycoplasma pneumoniae IgG, IgA and
IgM EIA methods based on the enrichment of Pl-protein (ThermoLabsystems, H
elsinki, Finland) (L) for the detection of acute infection. This evaluation
was performed in two independent routine clinical microbiology laboratorie
s. The first laboratory used samples preselected by IgG and IgM Platelia (R
) enzyme immunoassay (P) and the second used samples preseleced by Serion E
LISA Classic M. pneumoniae IgG, IgM (V). The L method was also compared to
the FDA approved method of ImmunoWell (R) K pneumoniae IgG and I-M (G). Whe
n the agreement of two methods was applied as a serologic criteria for an a
cute infection, the following ratios of acute to nonacute infection were ca
lculated 32/86 (totally 118) in the first and 20/72 (totally 92) in the sec
ond laboratory. In the first laboratory, the corresponding ratios by method
s were 35/83 (sensitivity 100%, specificity 96.5%), 31/87 (sensitivity 97%,
specificity 100%), and 55/63 (sensitivity 100%, specificity 79%) for the L
, P and G methods, respectively. In the second laboratory, the ratios were
21/71 (sensitivity 100%, specificity 99%), 16/76 (sensitivity 83%, specific
ity 100%), and 53/39 (sensitivity 100, specificity 69%) for the L, V and G
methods, respectively. taking into account that the tested sample material
was preselected by the P and V methods, which may have introduced some bias
in their favor, the newly developed L method utilizing PI-enriched protein
was found reliable for serodiagnosis of acute M. pneumoniae infection. The
method G was the least specific in detection of acute infection. (C) 2001
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.