The purpose of this study was to analyze student achievement data from the
first 3 years of the Memphis Restructuring Initiative (MRI). The MRI repres
ents one of the first efforts by an urban school district to move past trad
itional "top-down versus bottom-up" reform debates by providing systemic su
pport for "outside-in/inside-out" implementation and local co-construction
of externally-developed reform designs in schools. Analyses of academic ach
ievement focus on a state-of-the-art measure of "value added" assessments.
At the end of 3 years the reforming schools had produced generally positive
gains relative to locally matched control schools. Those results varied so
mewhat by reform type and by level of poverty in the communities being serv
ed. Based on the research methods used and the results, implications for fu
ture research and practice in educational reform are discussed.