In a packet-switched network, the service provider can charge users a state
-dependent price, which depends on the extent to which the network is conge
sted. Alternatively, one can charge users a longterm average price, which i
s set based on expected demand and capacity availability, but independent o
f instantaneous network conditions. In this paper, we compare the benefits
of different pricing schemes from the service provider, society, and consum
er perspectives. Our results suggest that adopting state-dependent pricing
improves both profit and total benefits to the society, but may be detrimen
tal to consumer benefits.