This study used performance-based testing (objective structured clinic
al evaluation, OSCE) to evaluate the skills of family physicians in as
sessing and managing the severe pain of a cancer patient, and evaluate
d a new method of education about the management of cancer pain. Twent
y-four primary care physicians completed a detailed pain assessment of
the same standardized cancer pain patient (Part A). A proctor observe
d the interviews and rated the physicians on a variety of pre-determin
ed items believed to be important for pain assessment. The physicians
were then allowed 5 min to answer management questions about the patie
nt's cancer pain (Part B). After reviewing each physician's performanc
e on Parts A and B, the proctor provided immediate feedback and instru
ction (Part C) on basic principles of cancer pain assessment and manag
ement. On average, the primary care Physicians asked 52% (+/- 4.5%) of
the indicated questions of a detailed pain assessment. Performance wa
s poorest in asking about previous pain history, temporal pattern of p
ain, and pain intensity. Performance on the pain assessment was best f
or eliciting pain location and pain-relieving factors. Primary care ph
ysicians obtained mean scores of 36% (+/- 3%) on Part B of the OSCE. A
lthough opioid therapy was frequently prescribed, only 42% of prescrip
tions were for regular administration. Performance on Parts A and B co
rrelated poorly with years in practice, and older physicians tended to
perform a less derailed pain assessment than their younger colleagues
. Most physicians enjoyed participating in this instructional format a
nd believed that the proctor feedback Increased the educational value
of the module. The results of our study suggest that many family physi
cians may be inadequate in their clinical assessment and management of
cancer pain. Our study supports the need for continuing education in
cancer pain management, regardless of years in practice. Further study
should evaluate the effects of different educational programs on clin
ical practice in patient care. (C) U.S. Cancer Pain Relief Committee,
1997.