Mo. Vysotsky et al., Molecular motions within self-assembled dimeric capsules with tetraethylammonium cations as guest, CHEM-EUR J, 7(20), 2001, pp. 4403-4410
Hydrogen-bonded, dimeric capsules of calix[4]arenes substituted at the wide
rim by four urea functions show unprecedented dynamic features when a tetr
aethyl ammonium cation is included as a guest. The seam of hydrogen bonds C
=O . . . (HN)(2)C=O in the equatorial region which holds the two calixarene
counterparts together changes its directionality fast (at 25 degreesC), wh
ile the dimer itself is kinetically stable on the NMR time scale. An energy
barrier of AG 49.9 kJ mol(-1) (T-c 276 K) was estimated for this reorienta
tion from variable-temperature (VT) NMR measurements. Lowering the temperat
ure to about -50 degreesC restricts also the rotation of the encapsulated t
etraethyl ammonium cation around a pseudo C-2-symmetry axis in the equatori
al plane of the capsule, while its rotation around the C, axis is still fas
t. As a result of this restriction two ethyl groups of the tetraethylammoni
um cation point towards the "poles" of the capsule, while the other pair li
es in the "equator" region. Variable-temperature H-1 NMR experiments led to
a barrier of DeltaG* = 54.8 kJ mol(-1) (T-c 306 K) for the exchange of the
se different ethyl groups. Studies with the ternary complex formed by a C-2
v-symmetrical tetraurea proved that both processes, reorientation of the hy
drogen bonds and rotation of the guest, take place independently. Molecular
dynamics simulations suggest that the capsule is strongly expanded by the
larger tetraethylammonium cation in comparison with benzene as guest. Thus,
on average only one N-H . . .O hydrogen bond is formed per urea function a
nd the interaction energy between the two tetraurea calixarenes is less fav
orable by about 15 kcal mol(-1). This is overcompensated by an energy gain
of about 36 kcal mol(-1) due to cation-a interactions. These results provid
e a rationale to understand the high stability of the complex inspite of th
e mobility of the hydrogen-bonded belt.