H. Migaud et al., CEMENTED FEMORAL REVISION WITH MORCELIZED ENDOSTEAL BONE ALLOGRAFTS PROTECTED BY A METALLIC MESH - RESULTS IN 19 HIPS AFTER 83 MONTHS FOLLOW-UP, Revue de chirurgie orthopedique et reparatrice de l'appareil moteur, 83(4), 1997, pp. 360-367
Purpose of the study To assess after 83 months of follow-up, the resul
ts of 19 femoral revisions carried out according to an original method
combining a cemented stem and bone reconstruction by means of impacte
d-morcelized bone allograft protected by a titanium mesh. Materials Tw
enty hips (18 patients mean aged 58 at surgery) were included between
1986 and 1991, Five hips had a least one previous prosthetic revision,
one hip was revised because of septic loosening. No patient was lost
for follow-up, but two had died during the follow-up period: one patie
nt died one month after surgery was excluded, one other died 7 years a
fter the index procedure and was included with his last hip rating. Lo
ss of femoral bone stock was severe according to the SOFCOT four stage
rating system : 2 femurs were grade II, 14 grade III, and 3 grade IV.
Femoral stem migration was assessed with landmarks recommended by Wal
ker. All the measurements were performed with a digitizer (OrthoGraphi
cs(TM)). Methods All the procedures were carried out through a postero
lateral approach, augmented by 4 trochanteric osteotomies and 5 distal
femoral windows. After prosthesis and cement removal, a bone plug was
placed into the medullary canal. Then, cancelous bone morcelized allo
grafts were impacted in the femoral defects through the medullary cana
l, A titanium mesh cylinder was placed into the femur to separate the
graft from the cement introduced later to obtain fixation of the revis
ion stem. The stem was extended about 5 centimeters over the distal ed
ge of the grafts in order to bridge the femoral defects. The mesh was
extended only in front of the grafts and was used to protect them from
excessive cement penetration. Results Functional improvement was noti
ceable since the Merle d'Aubigne Hip score improved from 9.8 to 16,3 a
t follow-up. The pain score improved from 2.1 to 5.5 and walking score
from 2.3 to 5. Adverse effects occured during the first cases and wer
e related to cement removal : 3 greater trochanter fractures, 5 distal
femoral perforations and 2 non displaced femoral shaft fractures, The
septic revision had recurrence of infection associated with radioluce
nt lines > 2 millimeters and the only one graft resorption. One trocha
nteric non-union was observed but no prosthetic dislocation. Only one
femoral stem migration (4.4 millimeters) was detected without any othe
r radiographic features of loosening after 9 years of follow-up, This
stem was considered as loosed, but was not revised because of few clin
ical symptoms. Only 2 radiolucent lines less than 2 millimeters at the
bone cement interface in Gruen's zones 3 to 5. Likewise, no radiograp
hic feature of stress-shielding was observed. On follow-up X-rays, 3 h
ips had corticalisation of the grafts, and 12 hips demonstrated normal
cancelous trabeculations in the grafts. Conclusion Satisfactory funct
ional and radiographic results were obtained with this method after 5
to 10 years of follow-up instead of severe preoperative femoral bone s
tock impairement. Likewise, we observed only one recurrence of looseni
ng diagnosed with the help of digitized X-ray examination. Only one si
gnificant (> 3.5 mm) femoral stem migration was detected. Radiographic
features of femoral reconstruction were observed but without histolog
ic proof of graft integration. This method uses a longer stem than the
''Exeter'', but avoids a high rate of femoral stem migration and appe
ars compatible with femoral bone reconstruction.