Ca. Mullin et al., ANTIFEEDANT EFFECTS OF SOME NOVEL TERPENOIDS ON CHRYSOMELIDAE BEETLES- COMPARISONS WITH ALKALOIDS ON AN ALKALOID-ADAPTED AND NONADAPTED SPECIES, Journal of chemical ecology, 23(7), 1997, pp. 1851-1866
Structure-dose-feeding deterrency relationships were compared between
the Colorado potato beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Say), and the w
estern corn rootworm, Diabrotica virgifera virgifera LeConte, using 15
alkaloids, terpenoids, and phenolic derivatives. The former species,
a specialist herbivore on selected alkaloid-rich Solanaceae species, w
as on average 100-times less sensitive to the antifeedant effects of a
lkaloids, but more similarly sensitive to the terpenoids and phenolics
than the fatter species, a generalist flower herbivore predominantly
on Graminae, Cucurbitaceae, and Compositae species. Antifeedant ED50 v
alues for the potato beetle and corn rootworm, each from closely relat
ed subfamilies of Chrysomelidae, ranged over four orders of dose magni
tude among the 15 compounds with major species differences in stereose
nsitivity to beta-hydrastines and analog sensitivity with the silphine
nes. Extremes in sensitivity ranged from silphinene, a rare tricyclic
sesquiterpene that is 53 times more active on the potato beetle to aco
nitine, which is 430 times more antifeedant to the corn rootworm. Amon
g silphinene and its two hydrolysis derivatives, there was not a stron
g correlation between antifeedant potency and injected toxicity for th
e two beetle species, but there was correlation between behavioral act
ivity and galeal taste cell electrophysiological threshold and frequen
cy responses. That all of the established GABA- and glycinergic compou
nds tested were antifeedant for both species suggests a shared molecul
ar mechanism for antifeedant taste chemoreception in these divergent C
hrysomelidae species. Moreover, the wide differences in antifeedant se
nsitivities among these and other chrysomelids to a suite of ligand-ga
ted ion channel antagonists implicate a common protein neuroreceptor t
ype with extraordinary heterogeneity in beetle taste.