Ra. Hunter et al., Sustained growth promotion, carcass and meat quality of steers slaughteredat three liveweights, AUST J EX A, 41(7), 2001, pp. 1033-1040
The experiment measured the effect of a sustained growth promotion strategy
on growth rate, carcass characteristics, and meat quality of Brahman and F
-1 Brahman crossbred steers. Meat quality was assessed objectively by labor
atory measurement and a subset of samples evaluated subjectively by consume
r taste panels. Steers were allocated to one of 12 treatment groups; 2 impl
ant strategies x 3 liveweights at slaughter x 2 nutritional finishing strat
egies. The 2 implant strategies were unimplanted controls and implantation
with 20 mg oestradiol-17 beta (Compudose) every 100 days. The target carcas
s weights at slaughter were about 220 kg (Australian domestic market), abou
t 280 kg (Korean market) and about 320 kg (Japanese market). Steers were fi
nished either at pasture or on a grain-based diet in a feedlot.
For every treatment group except where steers were finished in a feedlot fo
r the domestic market, the implant strategy resulted in significantly (P<0.
01) heavier final liveweights, significantly (P<0.01) greater cumulative li
veweight gains and significantly (P<0.05) heavier carcass weights. The magn
itudes of the significant liveweight responses ranged from 30 kg for pastur
e fed steers for the domestic market to 47 kg for pasture fed steers for th
e heavier weight Japanese market.
Repeated treatment with oestradiol-17<beta> had no significant effect on ca
rcass composition as determined by indices of carcass lean and carcass fat.
The additional yield of retail beef from implanted steers was principally
associated with increased carcass weight. The magnitude of the increase in
beef yield was 8 kg (n.s.) for domestic, feedlot steers; 15 kg (P<0.01) for
Korean, feedlot steers and 18 kg (P<0.001) for Japanese, feedlot steers.
In steers finished in the feedlot for the Korean and Japanese markets, sust
ained growth promotion was associated with a significant (P<0.01) decrease
in meat tenderness as measured by peak force. In contrast there was no such
effect in other groups measured (domestic market, feedlot finished and Jap
anese market, pasture finished). Consumer assessment of eating quality was
conducted on steaks from steers, finished in a feedlot for the Korean and J
apanese markets. At both slaughter weights there was no significant effect
of treatment on tenderness, juiciness, flavour, overall acceptability or me
at quality score which combined tenderness, juiciness, flavour and overall
quality. However, mean preference scores from implanted steers were consist
ently lower than those from control steers.
It was concluded that the aggressive implant strategy resulted in substanti
al increases in weight gain that were more pronounced during periods of mod
erate growth rate relative to periods of very low rates of gain. During per
iods of low weight gains or weight stasis there was little advantage from i
mplantation. Carcass composition was not significantly modified by treatmen
t with oestradiol. The effect of the aggressive implantation strategy on ea
ting quality of the beef was equivocal and further investigation is certain
ly warranted.