The recent synthesis of a crystalline compound containing Ti bonded to cycl
opentadienyl and a substituted dienyl fragment prompted the question of whe
ther Ti-C contacts that were found to be shorter than other such bonded con
tacts in the same molecule should be considered as short nonbonded contacts
or "nonclassical metal-to-saturated-carbon atom interactions", fitting the
description of agostic interactions. This question has a unique answer wit
hin the framework of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM). QTAI
M uses the measurable electron density to assign a molecular structure and
the physics of an open system to determine the nature of the bonded interac
tions. All of the classical bonding descriptors, when recast in terms of th
e topologies of the electron density and the pair density, are faithfully r
ecovered when QTAIM is applied to the hydrocarbon framework of the Ti compl
ex, thereby justifying its application to the analysis of the Ti-C interact
ions. No bond paths are found to link the Ti to the carbons exhibiting the
"short contacts", and the topology of the density gives no indication of an
incipient change in structure that would result in their formation.